What struck me when I reread it recently was a notable difference between Simms' version and the one in the book which claims it "contains sixteen representative Egyptian stories hitherto unpublished in the English language." This leads me to believe the stories are fairly intact as written.
Simms makes a few alterations, to make the story her own, I would assume. The Zaglouls' version reveals to us that Habi has no need of the offerings of others - no payment for the unique and dark service he renders. He also doesn't seem sinister, nor does he seem particularly foreboding. The Simms' version has Habi asking for the young boy's handmade flute - his prize possession and ultimately the expression of all that he is and all that is deeply true about him.
I find, now, that contrary to 10 years or so ago, I no longer like this idea. First, rereading the Zaglouls' book, I have a renewed sense of the spicy, rich character of these Egyptian folktales and perhaps even the people who told them. Suddenly, today, Simms' version reminds me of the Disney story of Ariel, the little mermaid who gave up her voice for love. She, too, was transformed, perhaps irrevocably. This makes me wonder if this idea is uniquely Western.
Habi does what he does, because he does what he does - he doesn't require payment from the recipient of his gifts - the one who makes the choice to undergo transformation in the name of true love will find there is enough payment to be made by the time the circle of the story closes.
Interestingly, to me, is that the original Little Mermaid story has an ending more in common with the Egyptian folktale than with the Disney movie.
Is there wisdom in this story? Lots.
Have I talked about any of it? I don't think so. I'm just beginning to keep company with this story - as it was originally told - the dial's on simmer and the savory essences are just beginning to be released. It's a complex tale, although at first glance I don't think it's obvious. It's taken me 10 years to hear a different resonance in it. It could take 10 more for me to find the still places within it that speak the most truthfully.
I can live with that.